We Tested the Option Strategies Everyone Teaches
Covered calls for monthly income. Iron condors that win most weeks. Protective puts as insurance. These are the option strategies most courses and videos teach. We replayed each of them on real NSE and BSE option prices, with every cost charged, and asked one plain question: did it beat simply holding the index?
What we tested
- Covered call: hold the index future and sell a call above the price every month.
- Protective put: hold the index future and buy a put below the price every month.
- Short put: sell a put below the price every month, with the full amount kept as cash.
- Iron condor, monthly and weekly: sell a call and a put either side of the price, and buy cheaper options further out so the loss is capped.
The yardstick is the plainest choice there is: hold the index and do nothing.
How we tested it
- Every trading day's official option prices from NSE (NIFTY and BANKNIFTY, January 2019 to November 2026) and BSE (SENSEX, December 2023 to November 2026).
- Positions open at the day's close and are held to expiry, where they settle on the exchange's settlement level. An option is used only on a day it actually traded.
- Costs on every leg: brokerage, STT at the rate of the time, exchange fees, GST, stamp duty and an allowance for the gap between buying and selling prices.
- For NIFTY and BANKNIFTY, how far from the price to sell or buy was chosen on 2019 to 2023 only, and the result judged on 2024 to 2026, years the choice never saw. SENSEX has too little history for that split, so its results are a first look.
- An iron condor is measured on the most it can lose, which is roughly the margin a broker blocks for it. The other strategies are measured on the full value of the position.
What Rs 1 lakh became
Show the numbers
| NIFTY, 2019-2026 | BANKNIFTY, 2019-2026 | SENSEX, 2024-2026 | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Hold the index | +1.17 | +1.10 | +0.11 |
| Covered call | +0.80 | +0.33 | +0.22 |
| Protective put | +1.20 | +1.61 | +0.05 |
| Short put | +0.19 | -0.02 | +0.03 |
| Iron condor, monthly | -1.00 | -1.00 | -0.04 |
| Iron condor, weekly | -1.00 | -1.00 | -1.00 |
Over seven years, Rs 1 lakh held in NIFTY became about Rs 2.17 lakh. The covered call made Rs 1.80 lakh and the short put Rs 1.19 lakh. Both iron condors lost everything on NIFTY and BANKNIFTY. The only strategy that kept up was the protective put, and that came mostly from one year: it paid out in the March 2020 crash.
The years nobody tuned for
Show the numbers
| NIFTY | BANKNIFTY | |
|---|---|---|
| Hold the index | +4.7 | +7.9 |
| Covered call | +4.1 | +4.6 |
| Protective put | +4.8 | +10.2 |
| Short put | 0.0 | -0.5 |
| Iron condor, monthly | -70.2 | -90.4 |
| Iron condor, weekly | -100.0 | -99.7 |
On years the settings never saw, the covered call and the short put earned less than the index. The protective put roughly matched NIFTY and beat BANKNIFTY, with smaller falls: its worst fall on BANKNIFTY was 10.8%, against 17.7% for holding the index. The iron condors were wiped out again.
Why the iron condor fails even though it usually wins
The weekly iron condor on SENSEX won 81% of its weeks. It still lost everything, because a winning week earned a small slice of the money at risk and a losing week took most of it. From January to June 2024 it won 23 weeks in a row, and Rs 1 lakh, reinvested each week, grew to about Rs 23 lakh. Election results week in June 2024 took 90% of that in one go.
That is the pattern behind most screenshots of steady option income: many small wins, and then the week that pays for all of them. A high win rate says nothing on its own. What matters is how much a win makes against how much a loss takes.
Does taking profit out help?
We replayed every strategy three ways: reinvest everything, set half of each new profit aside, or set all profit aside so only the original amount stays at risk. Money set aside is never put back.
Show the numbers
| Reinvest everything | Set half of profit aside | Set all profit aside | |
|---|---|---|---|
| NIFTY, monthly, 2019-2026 | 0.00 | +1.19 | +1.73 |
| BANKNIFTY, weekly, 2019-2026 | 0.00 | +1.36 | +1.82 |
| SENSEX, weekly, 2024-2026 | 0.00 | +4.13 | +3.40 |
Taking profit out turned wipe-outs into something left over, because the money set aside during the good runs was never put back at risk. But read it carefully. The SENSEX number comes from one lucky run at the very start; begin a few months later and that cushion never forms. And after each big loss the amount still invested shrank far below what a single SENSEX or NIFTY lot needs, so in real life the trading would have stopped. For the covered call, protective put and short put, which make smaller steadier amounts, taking profit out changed little.
And crypto? BTC and ETH options
Delta Exchange keeps no history for expired options, so we used Deribit, the largest crypto options exchange: every BTC and ETH option traded around its 08:00 UTC expiry time, each day from 2019, settled at Deribit's official settlement prices. Fees and slippage were set wider, for Delta. Same rules, same split: settings chosen on 2019 to 2023, judged on 2024 to 2026.
Show the numbers
| BTC | ETH | |
|---|---|---|
| Hold the coin | +18.55 | +14.53 |
| Covered call, monthly | +16.40 | +3.97 |
| Protective put, monthly | +10.38 | +27.96 |
| Short put, monthly | +1.02 | +0.39 |
| Iron condor, weekly | -1.00 | -1.00 |
Show the numbers
| BTC | ETH | |
|---|---|---|
| Hold the coin | +24.0 | -2.6 |
| Covered call, monthly | +18.2 | -14.8 |
| Protective put, monthly | +18.7 | +1.5 |
| Short put, monthly | +5.3 | -5.9 |
| Iron condor, weekly | -100.0 | -100.0 |
The same story, louder. Selling calls on BTC gave away the big up-moves that make up most of its return. The ETH protective put looks spectacular over the whole period only because it paid out in the 2021 to 2022 crash; on the years it was not tuned for, it earned 1.5% a year while ETH lost 2.6%. Short puts won most months and earned little. Weekly iron condors were wiped out on both coins. Rupees here are converted once at the start, ignoring exchange-rate moves.
Eight more methods, built more carefully
The simple versions above are what most people are taught. So we also tested more careful ones: cheaper ways to protect a holding, selling options only when they are expensive, with strikes picked by probability (delta), at most 5% of the money at risk per trade and an early exit if the loss reaches twice the premium collected, buying a straddle before scheduled events (Union Budget, election results, RBI and US Federal Reserve decisions), and calendar spreads. Same data, same costs, same rule: settings chosen on 2019 to 2023, judged on 2024 to 2026.
Show the numbers
| NIFTY | BANKNIFTY | BTC | ETH | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Hold | +4.7 | +7.9 | +24.0 | -2.6 |
| Protective put | +4.8 | +10.2 | +18.7 | +1.5 |
| Collar | +5.0 | +9.3 | +10.5 | -16.0 |
| Put spread hedge | +7.5 | +6.8 | +23.9 | +7.9 |
| Put only in downtrends | +5.4 | +7.2 | +23.9 | +10.7 |
| Sell only when expensive (weekly) | -1.6 | 0.0 | -5.5 | -1.5 |
| Straddle before events | -2.2 | -1.7 | -4.5 | -4.5 |
Only one family held up: hold the index or the coin, and add cheap protection. The put spread hedge beat holding NIFTY (7.5% a year against 4.7%, worst fall 12.1% against 15.7%). The collar beat holding BANKNIFTY (9.3% against 7.9%, worst fall 10.4% against 17.7%). On BTC, the put spread and the put bought only in downtrends earned the same as holding with smaller falls (worst fall about 36 to 38% against 48%). No single version won everywhere, and the margins are small.
Careful selling did not lose much, but it did not earn anything either: with smart strikes, small sizing and an early exit, it came out around zero after costs on every market. Straddles before events lost on every market, because the options usually already priced in a bigger move than the one that came. Calendar spreads lost heavily on every market (between 21% and 58% a year at a 10% stake per trade), so they are left off the chart.
What this means
- Holding the index was hard to beat. Most option overlays earned less, after costs.
- Insurance has a price. The protective put cost return in calm years and paid in the crash.
- A strategy that wins most weeks can still lose everything. Look at the size of the losses, not the win rate.
- Taking profit out of a risky strategy protects what you have made. It does not make the strategy good.
Limits of this test: daily closing prices only, so traders who adjust or close positions during the day are not modelled; costs are our estimate; SENSEX history is short; and the condors are measured with the whole amount at risk each cycle. SEBI's own study found that about 9 in 10 individual F&O traders lost money from FY22 to FY24.
Education and practice, not investment advice. You can try any of these ideas with practice money on JoNeTree before risking real money.